Skip to content
The Better Trip

Destinations

The Plaza vs The Beekman, A Thompson Hotel

Two New York landmarks, a 1907 château and an 1883 office block, and neither has a pool. The Plaza, from about $1,170 plus a $65 nightly fee, if you want Central Park across the road, tea under the Palm Court's stained glass and a spa upstairs; The Beekman, from about $505 plus $45.89 a night, if you would rather be in the Financial District under a nine-storey atrium of cast-iron galleries, with Tom Colicchio's Temple Court and Daniel Boulud's Le Gratin downstairs.

The Plaza across the Pond in Central Park, at nightThe icon

The Plaza

Hardenbergh's 1907 château on the corner of Central Park, where the Palm Court still serves tea under stained glass.

$$$$From about $1,170 a night

Choose The Plaza if

  • A first New York trip
  • Milestone birthdays
  • Eloise fans and their parents
  • Central Park mornings

The catch

The entry rooms do not face Central Park or Fifth Avenue. The Plaza King and Deluxe rooms look over the inner courtyard or 58th Street, and in January the Carnegie suites, with a partial park view, and the Pulitzer suites, over Fifth Avenue, cost more than $1,000 a night above them.

The Beekman, A Thompson Hotel: The atrium, rising nine storeys to its pyramid skylightThe design one

The Beekman, A Thompson Hotel

An 1883 office block built round a nine-storey atrium of cast-iron galleries, an interior landmark since 2024, with Colicchio and Boulud restaurants downstairs.

$$$From about $505 a night

Choose The Beekman, A Thompson Hotel if

  • Design hotels
  • Architecture lovers
  • Downtown sightseeing
  • Cocktails and jazz brunch

The catch

Laissez Faire, the club in the cellar, plays until 4am on Fridays and Saturdays, and The Bar Room serves until 1am, so low floors hear the weekend.

Which of our lists each one is on

Best forThe PlazaThe Beekman, A Thompson Hotel
Best design hotels in New YorkOn the listOn the list
Best central hotels in New YorkOn the listOn the list
Best hotels for food and drink in New YorkNot on the listOn the list

Both hotels on the same scales

The PlazaThe Beekman, A Thompson Hotel

Under the radarSee and be seen
ClassicContemporary
Smart spendSplurge
Central & walkableRemote escape
InternationalStrong sense of place
Beach & pool optionalBeach & pool central
FunctionalDesign-led

The Plaza

Area
Midtown, United States
From the centre
1.2 km
Airport
50 min from JFK
Price band
$$$$
Typical rate
From about $1,170 a night
Rooms
282
Last renovated
2008 (opened 1907)
Pool
No pool
Beach
None
Spa
Yes
Adults only
No
Restaurants
1
Parking
Yes
Selected by
Independent research
Last checked
October 2026

The Beekman, A Thompson Hotel

Area
Financial District, United States
From the centre
5.5 km
Airport
45 min from JFK
Price band
$$$
Typical rate
From about $505 a night
Rooms
287
Opened
2016
Pool
No pool
Beach
None
Spa
No
Adults only
No
Restaurants
2
Parking
Yes
MICHELIN Guide
One MICHELIN Key (2026)
Selected by
Independent research
Last checked
October 2026

The verdict

Two New York landmarks, a 1907 château and an 1883 office block, and neither has a pool. The Plaza, from about $1,170 plus a $65 nightly fee, if you want Central Park across the road, tea under the Palm Court's stained glass and a spa upstairs; The Beekman, from about $505 plus $45.89 a night, if you would rather be in the Financial District under a nine-storey atrium of cast-iron galleries, with Tom Colicchio's Temple Court and Daniel Boulud's Le Gratin downstairs.

The best things to do in New York, hand-picked

Hand-picked: only the best, one version of each, researched so you don’t have to.

See all

Questions people ask

Good questions about The Plaza vs The Beekman, A Thompson Hotel

The Plaza or The Beekman, A Thompson Hotel?

Two New York landmarks, a 1907 château and an 1883 office block, and neither has a pool. The Plaza, from about $1,170 plus a $65 nightly fee, if you want Central Park across the road, tea under the Palm Court's stained glass and a spa upstairs; The Beekman, from about $505 plus $45.89 a night, if you would rather be in the Financial District under a nine-storey atrium of cast-iron galleries, with Tom Colicchio's Temple Court and Daniel Boulud's Le Gratin downstairs.

Is The Plaza worth it?

Book The Plaza to sleep inside the château on the corner of Central Park, take tea in the Palm Court and be in the park before breakfast. Pay the small step to a Terrace Room King, and keep the park view for a suite budget, since even the Carnegie suites see it only in part. A famous, classic and very expensive hotel on the corner of Central Park, where the public rooms and the address are the point and the entry rooms face away from the park. Expect company in the lobby and the Palm Court, and expect to pay for the name.

Does The Plaza have a pool or a beach?

There is no pool. There is no beach; the nearest is a drive away.

Is The Beekman, A Thompson Hotel worth it?

Book The Beekman for a landmarked Victorian atrium, with the Brooklyn Bridge and the 9/11 Memorial on foot. Pay up to a Premium King on a high floor, and make the bar downstairs your night out rather than your alarm clock. Design and history are the whole argument: an 1883 office block wrapped round a nine-storey atrium of cast-iron galleries, with two big-name kitchens downstairs and a busy public bar on the floor of it. It is lively rather than restful, and there is no spa or pool.

Does The Beekman, A Thompson Hotel have a pool or a beach?

There is no pool. There is no beach; the nearest is a drive away.