Skip to content
The Better Trip

Destinations

Caruso, A Belmond Hotel vs Il San Pietro di Positano

Grand stays, above the sea or down at it. Caruso, A Belmond Hotel, from about €2,595, if you want frescoed halls and an infinity pool at the top of Ravello; Il San Pietro di Positano, from about €3,530, if you would rather have Three MICHELIN Keys and its own cove.

Caruso, A Belmond Hotel: The infinity pool beyond the wisteria pergolaThe grand one

Caruso, A Belmond Hotel

A medieval palace at the top of Ravello, with frescoed halls, terraced rose gardens and a heated infinity pool over the coast.

€€€€From about €2,595 a night

Choose Caruso, A Belmond Hotel if

  • Honeymoons and special occasions
  • A pool with one of the great views
  • Ravello's gardens and summer concerts
  • A quiet base above the coast

The catch

The entry Superior Room with Garden is on the ground floor of the Garden Wing and looks over the garden or the village, not the sea; the sea view starts with the Deluxe Sea View Room, about €200 to €900 a night more

Il San Pietro di Positano: The hotel stepped down the cliff east of PositanoThe escape

Il San Pietro di Positano

A 1970 hotel cut into the cliff below a chapel near Positano, with a lift through the rock to its own cove and boat.

€€€€From about €3,530 a night

Choose Il San Pietro di Positano if

  • Couples
  • Special occasions
  • Staying put
  • Food lovers

The catch

The entry Classic room is about 22 m² including its terrace and bathroom, with a shower; the hotel lists sunbeds on the terrace only from the 40 m² Elite rooms up

Which of our lists each one is on

Best forCaruso, A Belmond HotelIl San Pietro di Positano
Best beach hotels on the Amalfi CoastOn the listOn the list
Best quiet hotels on the Amalfi CoastOn the listOn the list
Best hotels with a view on the Amalfi CoastOn the listOn the list
Best hotels for food and drink on the Amalfi CoastNot on the listOn the list

Both hotels on the same scales

Caruso, A Belmond HotelIl San Pietro di Positano

InternationalStrong sense of place
Beach & pool optionalBeach & pool central
Smart spendSplurge
ClassicContemporary
QuietLively
Explore outsideStay at the hotel
Local & connectedSelf-contained

Caruso, A Belmond Hotel

Area
Ravello, Italy
From the centre
2.1 km
Airport
73 min from NAP
Price band
€€€€
Typical rate
From about €2,595 a night
Rooms
50
Last renovated
2005 (opened 1893)
Pool
Outdoor
Beach
None
Spa
Yes
Adults only
No
Restaurants
2
Parking
Yes
MICHELIN Guide
One MICHELIN Key (2026)
Selected by
Independent research
Last checked
October 2026

Il San Pietro di Positano

Area
Positano, Italy
From the centre
8.5 km
Airport
75 min from NAP
Price band
€€€€
Typical rate
From about €3,530 a night
Rooms
Not confirmed
Opened
1970
Pool
Outdoor
Beach
Private beach
Spa
Yes
Adults only
No
Restaurants
2
Parking
Yes
MICHELIN Guide
Three MICHELIN Keys (2026)
Selected by
Independent research
Last checked
October 2026

The verdict

Grand stays, above the sea or down at it. Caruso, A Belmond Hotel, from about €2,595, if you want frescoed halls and an infinity pool at the top of Ravello; Il San Pietro di Positano, from about €3,530, if you would rather have Three MICHELIN Keys and its own cove.

The best things to do on the Amalfi Coast, hand-picked

Hand-picked: only the best, one version of each, researched so you don’t have to.

See all

Questions people ask

Good questions about Caruso, A Belmond Hotel vs Il San Pietro di Positano

Caruso, A Belmond Hotel or Il San Pietro di Positano?

Grand stays, above the sea or down at it. Caruso, A Belmond Hotel, from about €2,595, if you want frescoed halls and an infinity pool at the top of Ravello; Il San Pietro di Positano, from about €3,530, if you would rather have Three MICHELIN Keys and its own cove.

Is Caruso, A Belmond Hotel worth it?

The palace at the top of Ravello, for the frescoes, the gardens and an infinity pool over the coast rather than a beach. Check availability for the Superior Sea View Junior Suite with Garden. A classic palace hotel of 50 rooms with an unmistakable sense of Ravello, where the pool, the gardens and the terrace dinners are the holiday and the price is at the very top. The village is on the doorstep; the beach is not.

Does Caruso, A Belmond Hotel have a pool or a beach?

It has an outdoor pool. There is no beach; the nearest is a drive away.

Is Il San Pietro di Positano worth it?

A cliff, a lift to the sea, a boat and a starred dinner, all without leaving the hotel. Check availability for an Elite Room. A cliff-side hotel built to be the whole holiday: the cove, the boat, the gardens and a starred dinner are all inside the gate, and Positano is a shuttle ride away. It is quiet, very expensive and made for couples.

Does Il San Pietro di Positano have a pool or a beach?

It has an outdoor pool. There is a private beach.