Two 1907 buildings on Fifth Avenue, one a hotel from the start, the other since 2023. The Plaza if you want Central Park across the road, the Palm Court's stained glass and twice the floor space in the entry room; The Fifth Avenue Hotel if you would rather pay from about $760 with no nightly fee, dine at Café Carmellini and have butler service whatever the room.
Hardenbergh's 1907 château on the corner of Central Park, where the Palm Court still serves tea under stained glass.
$$$$From about $1,170 a night
Choose The Plaza if
A first New York trip
Milestone birthdays
Eloise fans and their parents
Central Park mornings
The catch
The entry rooms do not face Central Park or Fifth Avenue. The Plaza King and Deluxe rooms look over the inner courtyard or 58th Street, and in January the Carnegie suites, with a partial park view, and the Pulitzer suites, over Fifth Avenue, cost more than $1,000 a night above them.
Two 1907 buildings on Fifth Avenue, one a hotel from the start, the other since 2023. The Plaza if you want Central Park across the road, the Palm Court's stained glass and twice the floor space in the entry room; The Fifth Avenue Hotel if you would rather pay from about $760 with no nightly fee, dine at Café Carmellini and have butler service whatever the room.
Good questions about The Plaza vs The Fifth Avenue Hotel
The Plaza or The Fifth Avenue Hotel?
Two 1907 buildings on Fifth Avenue, one a hotel from the start, the other since 2023. The Plaza if you want Central Park across the road, the Palm Court's stained glass and twice the floor space in the entry room; The Fifth Avenue Hotel if you would rather pay from about $760 with no nightly fee, dine at Café Carmellini and have butler service whatever the room.
Is The Plaza worth it?
Book The Plaza to sleep inside the château on the corner of Central Park, take tea in the Palm Court and be in the park before breakfast. Pay the small step to a Terrace Room King, and keep the park view for a suite budget, since even the Carnegie suites see it only in part. A famous, classic and very expensive hotel on the corner of Central Park, where the public rooms and the address are the point and the entry rooms face away from the park. Expect company in the lobby and the Palm Court, and expect to pay for the name.
Does The Plaza have a pool or a beach?
There is no pool. There is no beach; the nearest is a drive away.
Is The Fifth Avenue Hotel worth it?
Book it for the bank, the restaurant in its banking hall and the service every room gets, and pay up to The Corner King for the light. Sleeping inside the 1907 building itself starts at a Mansion suite. A new hotel built to feel like an old New York one: a 1907 bank on Fifth Avenue, maximalist interiors and a restaurant that opens its tables four weeks out. It is central, expensive and made for eating and drinking in, with a gym but no spa or pool.
Does The Fifth Avenue Hotel have a pool or a beach?
There is no pool. There is no beach; the nearest is a drive away.
The icon