Skip to content
The Better Trip

Destinations

Il San Pietro di Positano vs Borgo Santandrea

Hotels with their own sea, both with Three MICHELIN Keys. Il San Pietro di Positano, from about €3,530 with breakfast, if you want a 1970 hotel cut into the cliff, a lift through the rock to its cove and a free summer boat cruise; Borgo Santandrea, from about €2,745 with breakfast, if you would rather have a 2021 design hotel of mid-century pieces, hand-painted tile, lifts to a pebble beach and jetty.

Il San Pietro di Positano: The hotel stepped down the cliff east of PositanoThe escape

Il San Pietro di Positano

A 1970 hotel cut into the cliff below a chapel near Positano, with a lift through the rock to its own cove and boat.

€€€€From about €3,530 a night

Choose Il San Pietro di Positano if

  • Couples
  • Special occasions
  • Staying put
  • Food lovers

The catch

The entry Classic room is about 22 m² including its terrace and bathroom, with a shower; the hotel lists sunbeds on the terrace only from the 40 m² Elite rooms up

Borgo Santandrea: A Deluxe Suite with its terrace over the seaThe design one

Borgo Santandrea

Mid-century design and Italian craft down a cliff above Conca dei Marini, with Three MICHELIN Keys and lifts to its own beach.

€€€€From about €2,745 a night

Choose Borgo Santandrea if

  • Design lovers
  • Couples
  • Special occasion
  • Beach days

The catch

Among the coast's dearest: about €2,745 a night for a Superior room in June, with breakfast

Which of our lists each one is on

Best forIl San Pietro di PositanoBorgo Santandrea
Best beach hotels on the Amalfi CoastOn the listOn the list
Best design hotels on the Amalfi CoastNot on the listOn the list
Best quiet hotels on the Amalfi CoastOn the listOn the list
Best hotels with a view on the Amalfi CoastOn the listOn the list
Best hotels for food and drink on the Amalfi CoastOn the listOn the list

Both hotels on the same scales

Il San Pietro di PositanoBorgo Santandrea

Explore outsideStay at the hotel
Local & connectedSelf-contained
Beach & pool optionalBeach & pool central
Smart spendSplurge
Food secondaryDestination dining
InternationalStrong sense of place
FunctionalDesign-led

Il San Pietro di Positano

Area
Positano, Italy
From the centre
8.5 km
Airport
75 min from NAP
Price band
€€€€
Typical rate
From about €3,530 a night
Rooms
Not confirmed
Opened
1970
Pool
Outdoor
Beach
Private beach
Spa
Yes
Adults only
No
Restaurants
2
Parking
Yes
MICHELIN Guide
Three MICHELIN Keys (2026)
Selected by
Independent research
Last checked
October 2026

Borgo Santandrea

Area
Conca dei Marini, Italy
From the centre
2.8 km
Airport
69 min from NAP
Price band
€€€€
Typical rate
From about €2,745 a night
Rooms
52
Opened
2021
Pool
Outdoor
Beach
Private beach
Spa
Yes
Adults only
No
Restaurants
3
Parking
Yes
MICHELIN Guide
Three MICHELIN Keys (2026)
Selected by
Independent research
Last checked
October 2026

The verdict

Hotels with their own sea, both with Three MICHELIN Keys. Il San Pietro di Positano, from about €3,530 with breakfast, if you want a 1970 hotel cut into the cliff, a lift through the rock to its cove and a free summer boat cruise; Borgo Santandrea, from about €2,745 with breakfast, if you would rather have a 2021 design hotel of mid-century pieces, hand-painted tile, lifts to a pebble beach and jetty.

The best things to do on the Amalfi Coast, hand-picked

Hand-picked: only the best, one version of each, researched so you don’t have to.

See all

Questions people ask

Good questions about Il San Pietro di Positano vs Borgo Santandrea

Il San Pietro di Positano or Borgo Santandrea?

Hotels with their own sea, both with Three MICHELIN Keys. Il San Pietro di Positano, from about €3,530 with breakfast, if you want a 1970 hotel cut into the cliff, a lift through the rock to its cove and a free summer boat cruise; Borgo Santandrea, from about €2,745 with breakfast, if you would rather have a 2021 design hotel of mid-century pieces, hand-painted tile, lifts to a pebble beach and jetty.

Is Il San Pietro di Positano worth it?

A cliff, a lift to the sea, a boat and a starred dinner, all without leaving the hotel. Check availability for an Elite Room. A cliff-side hotel built to be the whole holiday: the cove, the boat, the gardens and a starred dinner are all inside the gate, and Positano is a shuttle ride away. It is quiet, very expensive and made for couples.

Does Il San Pietro di Positano have a pool or a beach?

It has an outdoor pool. There is a private beach.

Is Borgo Santandrea worth it?

The coast's design hotel, with its own beach, a starred terrace and Three MICHELIN Keys, from about €2,745 a night with breakfast. Check availability for the Deluxe Room Sea View & balcony. A design-led cliff hotel where the beach, the pool and a starred dinner are all on the property, at the very top of the coast's prices. Amalfi is a shuttle ride away rather than a walk.

Does Borgo Santandrea have a pool or a beach?

It has an outdoor pool. There is a private beach.