Skip to content
The Better Trip

Destinations

Hotel Santa Lucia vs Hotel Tramonto d'Oro

Two family-run four-stars on the bus route, by the beach or above the sea. Hotel Santa Lucia, from about €225 with breakfast, under half the rate, if you want flat Minori, the beach three minutes' walk away and a lift to every floor; Hotel Tramonto d'Oro, from about €520 with breakfast, if you would rather have Praiano's rooftop pool looking west to Positano and Capri, with buses at the door.

Hotel Santa Lucia: The breakfast buffet on the covered terraceThe smart money

Hotel Santa Lucia

A family-run four-star in flat Minori, by a Roman villa and three minutes from the beach, breakfast included, from about €225.

€€From about €225 a night

Choose Hotel Santa Lucia if

  • Families with young children
  • Travellers without a car
  • Couples on a budget
  • Guests who avoid steps

The catch

Rooms on the street side face the SS163 coast road and pick up traffic noise

Hotel Tramonto d'Oro: The rooftop pool above the bay towards PositanoThe view

Hotel Tramonto d'Oro

A family-run hotel in the centre of Praiano whose rooftop pool faces west, to Positano, Capri and the sunset.

€€€€From about €520 a night

Choose Hotel Tramonto d'Oro if

  • Sunset watchers
  • Couples
  • Travelling the coast by bus
  • Drivers

The catch

Rooms are compact: the Superior with a partial sea view is 20 m², and the sea is seen only in part, from its 4 m² balcony

Which of our lists each one is on

Best forHotel Santa LuciaHotel Tramonto d'Oro
Best value hotels on the Amalfi CoastOn the listNot on the list
Best central hotels on the Amalfi CoastOn the listNot on the list
Best quiet hotels on the Amalfi CoastNot on the listOn the list
Best hotels with a view on the Amalfi CoastNot on the listOn the list

Both hotels on the same scales

Hotel Santa LuciaHotel Tramonto d'Oro

Smart spendSplurge
Central & walkableRemote escape
CouplesFamilies
IntimateLarge resort
InternationalStrong sense of place
Beach & pool optionalBeach & pool central
PolishedCharacterful

Hotel Santa Lucia

Area
Minori, Italy
From the centre
2.6 km
Airport
66 min from NAP
Price band
€€
Typical rate
From about €225 a night
Rooms
25
Pool
No pool
Beach
Public beach nearby
Spa
No
Adults only
No
Restaurants
1
Parking
Yes
Selected by
Independent research
Last checked
October 2026

Hotel Tramonto d'Oro

Area
Praiano, Italy
From the centre
7.2 km
Airport
76 min from NAP
Price band
€€€€
Typical rate
From about €520 a night
Rooms
38
Opened
1963
Pool
Rooftop
Beach
Public beach nearby
Spa
No
Adults only
No
Restaurants
1
Parking
Yes
Selected by
Independent research
Last checked
October 2026

The verdict

Two family-run four-stars on the bus route, by the beach or above the sea. Hotel Santa Lucia, from about €225 with breakfast, under half the rate, if you want flat Minori, the beach three minutes' walk away and a lift to every floor; Hotel Tramonto d'Oro, from about €520 with breakfast, if you would rather have Praiano's rooftop pool looking west to Positano and Capri, with buses at the door.

The best things to do on the Amalfi Coast, hand-picked

Hand-picked: only the best, one version of each, researched so you don’t have to.

See all

Questions people ask

Good questions about Hotel Santa Lucia vs Hotel Tramonto d'Oro

Hotel Santa Lucia or Hotel Tramonto d'Oro?

Two family-run four-stars on the bus route, by the beach or above the sea. Hotel Santa Lucia, from about €225 with breakfast, under half the rate, if you want flat Minori, the beach three minutes' walk away and a lift to every floor; Hotel Tramonto d'Oro, from about €520 with breakfast, if you would rather have Praiano's rooftop pool looking west to Positano and Capri, with buses at the door.

Is Hotel Santa Lucia worth it?

A family-run four-star in flat, central Minori, beside a Roman villa and three minutes from the beach, with breakfast included from about €225 a night. Check availability for a Superior Room at the back. A small, family-run town hotel priced as a base rather than a destination, with the beach, the buses and the ferries a few minutes away on the level. You come for the price, the breakfast and the easy access, and spend your days out on the coast.

Does Hotel Santa Lucia have a pool or a beach?

There is no pool. A public beach is within walking distance.

Is Hotel Tramonto d'Oro worth it?

The Praiano hotel for the sunset from a rooftop pool, with a family welcome and the bus to Positano and Amalfi at the door. Check availability for a Classic Room with sea view terrace. A small, family-run hotel where the rooftop pool and the sunset over Positano are the point, with the character of a place run by the same family for more than seventy years rather than the polish of a luxury hotel. Praiano is quiet, and Positano and Amalfi are a bus ride away.

Does Hotel Tramonto d'Oro have a pool or a beach?

It has a rooftop pool. A public beach is within walking distance.