Skip to content
The Better Trip

Destinations

Where to eat at and around The Fifth Avenue Hotel

You are at the top of NoMad, four blocks below Koreatown and two above Madison Square Park, and the eating follows the map: Korean to the north and east, the big names around the park to the south. The hotel's own tables come first, Café Carmellini in the double-height banking hall from 7am and the Portrait Bar from 5pm, and both book on Resy like any restaurant in the city. Everything below is within seven minutes of the door, and most of it within five.

Worth the table

The tables at this hotel that are a reason to come, and how hard they are to get.

The Fifth Avenue Hotel: Café Carmellini in the double-height banking hall

Café Carmellini

Michelin recommendedChef Andrew CarmelliniItalian and French cooking in the double-height former banking hallSmart casual

The reason to eat in. Andrew Carmellini, the James Beard Award winner best known for Locanda Verde, cooks Italian and French here in the bank's old hall: double height, two sculptural trees, sapphire velvet booths and balcony tables for two looking down on the room. The squab en croûte with foie gras and the crab mille-feuille are the dishes it is known for, the list runs to 1,800 bottles under Master Sommelier Josh Nadel, and it was No. 39 on North America's 50 Best Restaurants in 2025. The MICHELIN Guide lists it without a star. Dinner runs nightly from 5pm to 10pm and tables are released four weeks ahead, so book the day they open; breakfast, 7am to 11am every day, is the easy way into the hall.

Book well ahead: tables go weeks out

The Fifth Avenue Hotel: The Portrait Bar from above

The Portrait Bar

Panelled cocktail bar hung with portraits, around a carved stone fireplaceDinner only

Guests have it to themselves as a lounge from 8am to 5pm; at 5pm it opens to everyone and runs until 1am in the week, 2am on Fridays and Saturdays and midnight on Sundays. The room is the draw: dark wood panelling hung with paintings, photographs and drawings around a carved stone fireplace. Darryl Chan's list travels, from a coconut and calamansi Cebu Island to an aperitivo highball called Torino, and the bar was No. 71 on the extended list of North America's 50 Best Bars for 2026. Resy takes bookings 14 days ahead for up to four.

Reserve ahead

On our shortlists

Within ten minutes on foot

  • KazuNori NoMad

    1 min walk

    Hand roll counter · $$

    A few doors along West 28th Street, a counter from the group behind Sugarfish that serves hand rolls and almost nothing else. The set menus are the order: three rolls for $20, four for $25, five with toro and lobster for $31 and six for $36, with sake or Sapporo to drink. It is a no-tipping restaurant, and it runs 11:30am to 11pm, to 11:30pm on Fridays and Saturdays, so it covers a late lunch or a first dinner off a flight.

    Walk in15 West 28th Street

  • Bagel shop and coffee · $

    Wood-fired bagels around the corner on Broadway, open 7am to 4pm every day, and the breakfast to have when $42 for eggs in the banking hall is more than you want to spend. The Salmon Classic is smoked salmon, cream cheese, tomato, red onion and capers; the Classic 2.0 swaps in pastrami-spiced salmon, scallion cream cheese and pickled green tomato. For something hot, the BEC is bacon, two fried eggs and white cheddar. Espresso, drip and cold brew are on the board.

    Walk in1188 Broadway

  • Nubeluz

    2 min walk

    Cocktail bar on the 50th floor · $$$

    José Andrés's cocktail bar on the top floor of the Ritz-Carlton NoMad, a few doors west along 28th Street, with 270-degree views over Manhattan from 50 floors up. Martin Brudnizki's studio, which also dressed The Fifth Avenue Hotel, designed the room, and the list is modern takes on classic cocktails with small bites. Reservations are required and open 30 days ahead, a no-show costs $35 a head, everyone must be 21 or over, and the dress code turns away athletic wear, shorts, caps and flip-flops.

    Book well ahead: tables go weeks outThe Ritz-Carlton New York, NoMad, 25 West 28th Street

  • Okdongsik

    4 min walk

    Korean pork soup counter · $$

    A one-dish restaurant from Seoul, where the original has held a MICHELIN Bib Gourmand since 2018. The dish is dweji gomtang: pork shoulder simmered with radish, onion, garlic and ginger into a clear broth seasoned only with salt, poured over rice and thin slices of pork. The room is one small counter. It opens at 8am on weekdays and runs to 10pm, with weekend hours of 11am to 3pm and 5pm to 10pm, which makes a bowl of soup a real alternative to breakfast in the hotel.

    Walk in13 East 30th Street

  • Patent Pending

    5 min walk

    Cellar cocktail bar · $$$

    A cocktail bar in the basement of the old Gerlach Hotel, the building where Nikola Tesla lived and experimented with radio waves, and the list leans on him with drinks named Radio Waves and Wonder of Physics. Most cocktails are $22, the more elaborate ones up to $34, with bites such as devilled eggs, lobster bao and a Korean fried chicken sandwich. It opens at 5pm every day, closing at midnight Sunday to Wednesday and 2am Thursday to Saturday, and seats walk-ins first come, first served.

    Walk in49 West 27th Street

  • New Wonjo

    7 min walk

    Korean barbecue, open until 5am · $$

    Four blocks north is West 32nd Street, the heart of Koreatown, and New Wonjo, which dates from 1993, does table-grilled Korean barbecue on it. It keeps the street's hours: 10am to 5am every day, with the kitchen open until 4am. The combinations for two are the order, from pork belly, jowl and marinated pork rib at $89.95 to the Wonjo Combo of marinated Angus short rib, brisket and pork belly at $105.95, each with a choice of stew. Book on Resy for a dinner table.

    Reserve ahead23 West 32nd Street

  • Tasting menu, three MICHELIN stars · $$$$

    Daniel Humm's restaurant at the base of an Art Deco building on the corner of Madison Square Park, with three MICHELIN stars. Dinner is a six-course seasonal tasting menu at $385 a head, with a choice of dishes on some courses and the option to eat it fully plant-based; the bar serves a shorter tasting for $255 and takes walk-ins for snacks and cocktails. Reservations open on the first of each month for the whole of the next and cannot be cancelled or refunded, so book as soon as your dates are fixed.

    Book well ahead: tables go weeks out11 Madison Avenue

The best places to stay and eat, in your inbox

New cities, the tables worth booking and the hotels we would choose, catches included. Occasional emails, one click to unsubscribe.

Breakfast

Breakfast is not in the standard room-only rate; the hotel sells packages that include it. Café Carmellini serves it in the banking hall from 7am to 11am every day. The Fifth Avenue Breakfast, eggs any style with potatoes, bacon or sausage, roasted tomato and toast, comes with orange juice and coffee for $42; L'Express, an assortment of house pastries with cultured butter and preserves, is $34 on the same terms; two eggs with potatoes and toast are $26 on their own. At weekends a two-course brunch at $75 takes over from 11:30am, and in-room dining runs around the clock. The cheaper mornings are close: Black Seed's bagels from 7am two minutes away, or Okdongsik's pork soup from 8am on weekdays.

The best places to stay in New York

Ten hotels, each here for a different reason.

See all

Questions people ask

Good questions about The Fifth Avenue Hotel

Where can I eat near The Fifth Avenue Hotel?

You are at the top of NoMad, four blocks below Koreatown and two above Madison Square Park, and the eating follows the map: Korean to the north and east, the big names around the park to the south. The hotel's own tables come first, Café Carmellini in the double-height banking hall from 7am and the Portrait Bar from 5pm, and both book on Resy like any restaurant in the city. Everything below is within seven minutes of the door, and most of it within five. KazuNori NoMad, 1 min walk. Black Seed Bagels NoMad, 2 min walk. Nubeluz, 2 min walk.

Where should I eat at The Fifth Avenue Hotel?

Café Carmellini. The reason to eat in. Andrew Carmellini, the James Beard Award winner best known for Locanda Verde, cooks Italian and French here in the bank's old hall: double height, two sculptural trees, sapphire velvet booths and balcony tables for two looking down on the room. The squab en croûte with foie gras and the crab mille-feuille are the dishes it is known for, the list runs to 1,800 bottles under Master Sommelier Josh Nadel, and it was No. 39 on North America's 50 Best Restaurants in 2025. The MICHELIN Guide lists it without a star. Dinner runs nightly from 5pm to 10pm and tables are released four weeks ahead, so book the day they open; breakfast, 7am to 11am every day, is the easy way into the hall.

Our verdict

Book it for the bank, the restaurant in its banking hall and the service every room gets, and pay up to The Corner King for the light. Sleeping inside the 1907 building itself starts at a Mansion suite.

Last checked: October 2026

From about

$760 a night

Prices on